Choosing Between Black and Brown Mascara: A Comprehensive Guide

When it comes to mascara, the eternal debate often centers around black or brown. While black mascara tends to steal the spotlight for its bold and classic look, brown mascara is its understated companion, offering a softer and more natural effect. To help you decide when to reach for each mascara color, we've gathered insights from makeup artists and beauty experts. Read on to discover the benefits of both black and brown mascaras and learn when and how to choose between them.

Benefits of Brown Mascara

• Great for Lighter Eyes: Brown mascara is a favorite among those with lighter eye colors, such as blue, green, or hazel. It accentuates and complements these natural eye hues without overpowering them.

• Perfect for Natural Looks: If you prefer a subtle and natural appearance, brown mascara is your go-to choice. It offers length and volume without the dramatic impact of black mascara. We suggest that brown mascara is ideal for everyday wear when you want a polished look without appearing heavily made up.

Benefits of Black Mascara

• Universally Flattering: Black mascara is versatile and complements all eye colors, from light to dark. It creates a striking contrast against the natural eye color, making your eyes pop, as Elyse Reneau highlights.

• Bold and Glamorous: When you're aiming for a dramatic and intense eye look, black mascara is the answer. It defines your lashes and pairs exceptionally well with smoky eyeshadows and daring shades.

• Lash Definition: Unlike brown mascara, which offers subtle definition, black mascara has the power to transform your eyes. With a few coats, it can make your lashes look longer and thicker, making it particularly beneficial for individuals with light or blonde lashes.

In the blackest of blacks, our Eye Am Beautiful Mascara provides a lash-extending and volumizing effect. With a silicone brush, treat your lashes with more volume, length, and strength. This creamy formula also delights your lashes with moisture and lash elasticity.

This formula uses natural wax that is emollient and hydrating for the lashes. Also, it truly enhances the look of the lashes, lengthens and thickens the lashes without being clumpy and because it stays hydrated it doesn’t flake throughout the day. It’s also buildable so you can apply another coat for a more dramatic look!

What to Consider When Choosing Between the Two

• Desired Definition: Consider how defined you want your lashes to be. If you're going for a precise, defined look, black mascara excels in elongating and volumizing lashes. In contrast, brown mascara provides a softer and more natural effect.

• Occasion: Tailor your mascara choice to the occasion. Opt for brown mascara for everyday or professional settings, as it imparts a subtle touch. Reserve black mascara for special events or evenings when you want to create a more striking appearance.

• Eyeshadow Preferences: Think about the eyeshadow styles and colors you prefer. Light neutral shades pair wonderfully with brown mascara, especially those with warm undertones. On the other hand, bold eyeshadow colors and smoky shades harmonize beautifully with black mascara.

• Personal Style: Your personal style can also guide your mascara selection. If you lean toward a softer and more understated appearance, brown mascara aligns well with your aesthetic. Conversely, if you prefer a bold and captivating look, black mascara is your ally.

The Final Takeaway

In the black vs. brown mascara debate, why not try both? Experiment with each color to see which one suits your mood and style best. You can even take it a step further by wearing one color on each eye for a side-by-side comparison or embracing a color-blocking moment.

Mascara trends have recently leaned toward length over volume, with some opting for black on top and brown on the bottom lashes to achieve a softer and less intense look. When it comes to makeup, the possibilities are endless, so have fun exploring and finding your perfect mascara match.